Bench Strength - The Telling Factor
India have yet again conceded vital advantage by allowing a champion side like
Australia to crawl their way from a precarious position on the first day to take
inevitable steps towards recording a significant and morale boosting win in the
first of the four test series of the crucial Border-Gavaskar Trophy at the
Chinnaswamy Stadium in Bangalore. But more than berating the Indian team for the
lacklustre performance, especially so with the bat, there is a significant and
enlightening annotation for the Indian administration.
The Australian experience is perhaps the best way to drive home the point. India
did well to peg back the Australians after the latter won the toss. With
Australia looking shaky at 149 for the loss of four wickets, India had more than
just a foot in the door. And this is why. Australia are a different team from
the one that lost the previous series by a 2-1 margin. Sure, they are smarting
from that memorable turn around at Eden Gardens which gave India domain over the
reigning world champions. But that has not tarnished their self-belief by any
stretch of the imagination. In fact perhaps it has made them more quietly and
fiercely determined to set the record straight they way they see it. But that is
not the point.
The doggedly defiant Steve Waugh, who incidentally made his debut against India,
no longer holds the reins of the mighty team from down under. The hard-line
approach of Waugh has made way for an aggressive and superiorly confident
captain in Ricky Ponting. But Australia set foot on Indian shores without the
services of their skipper who sustained a finger injury, elevating Adam
Gilchrist to a position yet uncrowned on him. While Adam Gilchrist would have
been ecstatic at the opportunity to lead the side in such a significant series
that could bring honors elusive to the Australian team since the 70's, he must
have had a his heart thumping at such a tremendous responsibility thrust on his
shoulders in such a foreign land.
To say that Ricky Ponting's absence equalises the absence of Sachin Tendulkar,
tortured by a chronic tennis elbow, would be misleading. Sachin Tendulkar's
presence in the final eleven has more bearing than that of Ponting in the
Australian side. Australia are like a well oiled machine, not given to the
vagaries and flamboyance of their players. Their approach is a rather clinical
methodology, laying single minded emphasis on getting the basic right. India, on
the other hand, have the habit of accommodating the accomplishments and
capabilities of their players which also means having to make some compromises
that could well affect the result and consequently, morale of the team.
Most former and senior Australian ex-players were astonished to find the name of
young debutant Michael Clarke in the list of the final eleven, terming it as too
much of a gamble for the first Test of a series, whose victory would be their
crowning glory. Simon Katich has been a name floating in cricketing circles with
less than ten Tests to his credit. However, the reputation of the man precedes
his place on the field. Simon Katich, rated very high in the Australian media,
was left in the dark in the series against Sri Lanka in spite of a valiant and
pugnacious knock of 125 against India in the Sydney Test when Australia
struggled to avoid the follow-on.
Damien Martyn's resurrected career continues to face crucifixion in the media
despite boasting on a Test average of above forty. Darren Lehmann is constantly
fighting to secure a consistent place in the side despite being such a forceful
player in the squad. Judging by the performance of the relative newcomers in
Simon Katich and Michael Clarke, the two senior players will in all likelihood
go fighting down into the twilight of their careers. Simon Katich has once again
reaffirmed the management's faith in him with a valiant knock of eighty-one in a
hundred partnership with the twenty-three year old Michael Clarke that swung the
momentum for Australia and nullified Indian efforts earlier in the day.
Michael Clarke, who initially looked like a chicken just hatched, came into his
own and when Australia relaunched their fight back on the morning of the second
day's play, he had aged into a mature and self assured batsman. Such was his
composure and command over the proceedings, he made stand-in skipper, Adam
Gilchrist, seem insignificant despite carving a terrific a-run-a-ball century.
Gilchrist's jubilation at not just his own century but also, that of the young
debutant, exuded the tremendous pride that the players take in representing
their land. Michael Clarke's conscious decision to replace his helmet with the
baggy green cap, presented to him earlier by Shane Warne, was a gesture not
unnoticed.
Michael Clarke's tremendous 150 on debut was not just celebrated by Les and
Debbie Clarke, Margaret and Raymond Fox. Apart from his family, it was a great
validation for the team management to blood the young, hungry and more
importantly, in-form player at the start of such a crucial series. Australia's
depth in batting has not suffered by the loss of Steve Waugh and the temporary
absence of Ricky Ponting.
India's woes are for all to see. As they struggled to come to terms in the one
day arena with the collective disaster of their batting prowess, there is such a
deep chasm when it comes to finding suitable replacements who are not just
warming the benches but breathing down the neck of the players who do make the
cut. Sachin's absence is not the only cause. There are deeper issues that have
to be addressed. That requires a significant change in mind set. With so much
weighing on their minds, the last thing the team needs is excess baggage.